PREMAL — Privacy-Preserving ML with FHE

A curated map of papers on machine learning under Fully Homomorphic Encryption. Each entry is summarized into a per-paper page with pipeline and architecture diagrams, threat model, results, and limitations.

Scope: end-to-end FHE for ML — inference, training, federated aggregation. Out of scope: pure MPC, pure differential privacy, and trusted-execution-environment work. Hybrid schemes are in.

At a glance

50 papers · 2018–2025 · schemes: CKKS (×27), Hybrid (×9), TFHE (×7), BFV (×2), BGV (×2), FHE (scheme not specified) (×1), Paillier (PHE) (×1), survey (covers lattice, integer, (R)LWE, NTRU) (×1) · domains: generic-vision (×25), medical (×15), tabular (×5), iot (×4), finance (×1) · tasks: inference (×36), federated-round (×12), training (×2)

Practical and Private Hybrid ML Inference with Fully Homomorphic Encryption 2025

Biswas et al. · TFHE-based RLWE (hybrid client/server)
Hybrid FHE inference: server runs encrypted linear layers, client runs plaintext ReLU, no bootstrapping.

Recent advances of privacy-preserving machine learning based on (Fully) Homomorphic Encryption 2024

Hong · survey (BFV, BGV, CGGI/TFHE, CKKS, mixed)
Tour of FHE-based PPML across four FHE generations, mixed-mode schemes, and hardware acceleration.

Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning With Fully Homomorphic Encryption for Deep Neural Network 2022

Lee et al. · RNS-CKKS
First standard ResNet-20 on encrypted CIFAR-10 under RNS-CKKS with bootstrapping; 92.43% accuracy in ~3 h.

A Survey of Deep Learning Architectures for Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning With Fully Homomorphic Encryption 2022

Podschwadt et al. · survey (BFV, BGV, CKKS, TFHE, YASHE)
Cross-cuts FHE-PPML works by NN layer, activation, packing, bootstrapping and proposes hardware-independent comparison metrics.

Towards the AlexNet Moment for Homomorphic Encryption: HCNN, the First Homomorphic CNN on Encrypted Data With GPUs 2021

Badawi et al. · BFV
First GPU-accelerated FHE CNN; MNIST in 5.16 s and CIFAR-10 in 304 s under BFV.

A Survey on Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning with Fully Homomorphic Encryption 2020

Pulido-Gaytan et al. · survey (covers lattice, integer, (R)LWE, NTRU)
Survey maps FHE families, bootstrapping, and MLaaS approaches to position privacy-preserving ML directions.

All papers

Sorted by year (newest first), then by single-inference latency (ascending). Hover the inference time to see the hardware it was measured on.

Title Year Hook FHE Model Dataset Accuracy Inference (s) Code
Touch of Privacy: A Homomorphic Encryption-Powered Deep Learning Framework for Fingerprint Authentication
FHE fingerprint matching
2025 CKKS-encrypted Euclidean matching of CNN fingerprint features hits 99.06% accuracy in 0.025 s per comparison. CKKS CNN SOCOFing 99.06% (EER 0.40%, TAR 99.19%, FAR 0%) 0.025 —
Evaluation of Privacy-aware Support Vector Machine (SVM) Learning using Homomorphic Encryption
CKKS SVM parameter sweep
2025 Parameter sweep of CKKS-encrypted SVM-Linear vs SVM-Poly on Iris: ring dimension and modulus dominate cost. CKKS SVM Iris 96.7% (matches plaintext) 0.2029 —
Evaluation of Privacy-Preserving Support Vector Machine (SVM) Learning Using Homomorphic Encryption
CKKS SVM parameter sweep
2025 Parameter sweep of CKKS-encrypted SVM inference on Iris using OpenFHE; ring dimension and modulus dominate cost. CKKS SVM Iris 96.7% (0.0 vs plaintext) 0.2029 GitHub
Application of Machine Learning-NLP Approach With Fully Homomorphic Encryption Techniques in Medical PII Data
FHE on medical PII
2025 Benchmarks Concrete-ML SGD, XGBoost, and Decision Tree on synthetic medical PII text classification. TFHE (via Concrete-ML) SGD / XGBoost / Decision Tree Synthetic GAN-generated medical PII (100k) 100% (SGD, XGB); 91.7% (DT) — matches plaintext 0.41 —
Comparison of Fully Homomorphic Encryption and Garbled Circuits Approaches in Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning
FHE vs GC apples-to-apples
2025 Side-by-side benchmark: CKKS FHE vs TinyGarble2.0 GC on the same 2-layer NN. CKKS (vs Garbled Circuits) FCNN Synthetic 3-dim input vectors Max deviation: GC 23.46%, FHE 121.69% vs plaintext 5.07723 GitHub
Comparison of Fully Homomorphic Encryption and Garbled Circuit Techniques in Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning Inference
FHE vs GC head-to-head
2025 Head-to-head SEAL-CKKS vs TinyGarble2.0 on a 2-layer NN — GC ~161x slower, FHE ~20,912x slower than plaintext. CKKS FCNN Synthetic 3-dim inputs Output deviation up to 121.69% (FHE) vs 23.46% (GC) from plaintext 5.07723 GitHub
Practical and Private Hybrid ML Inference with Fully Homomorphic Encryption
Hybrid client/server FHE
2025 Hybrid FHE inference: server runs encrypted linear layers, client runs plaintext ReLU, no bootstrapping. TFHE-based RLWE (hybrid client/server) ResNet-20 / ResNet-18 / ResNet-34 Multiple 90.00% on CIFAR-10 (-1.70 vs ORION) 13.65 —
A privacy preserving machine learning framework for medical image analysis using quantized fully connected neural networks with TFHE based inference
4-bit QAT FCNN on MedMNIST
2025 Quantization-aware FCNN runs encrypted MedMNIST inference under TFHE with near-plaintext accuracy. TFHE FCNN MedMNIST (Pneumonia/Breast/Blood) 88.88% Pneumonia (-0.01 vs plaintext) 119.55 —
Activate Me!: Designing Efficient Activation Functions for Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning with Fully Homomorphic Encryption
Scheme-switching ReLU
2025 Compares square, Chebyshev-50 poly-ReLU, and a CKKS<->TFHE scheme-switching ReLU on LeNet-5 and ResNet-20. hybrid (CKKS+TFHE) LeNet-5 and ResNet-20 MNIST + CIFAR-10 ResNet-20 89.8% (-2.4 vs plaintext) with scheme-switching; 83.8% (-8.4) with poly-approx 1145.0 —
An Efficient and Privacy-Preserving Federated Learning Approach Based on Homomorphic Encryption
DREL + BFV FedAvg
2025 Dynamic per-layer quantization enables BFV-encrypted FedAvg with 192-bit security and >99% encryption-time savings vs Paillier. BFV CNN + FNN Multiple Up to +0.24% vs No-PPFL; worst -0.39% vs CKKS (FMNIST) — —
HHEML: Hybrid Homomorphic Encryption for Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning on Edge
FPGA Pasta HHE
2025 First end-to-end FPGA HHE pipeline: dual-XOF Pasta accelerator cuts MNIST client-side latency 50x. hybrid (Pasta SE + FHE via GuardML) N/A MNIST Not reported — —
Federated Learning: An approach with Hybrid Homomorphic Encryption
Hybrid HE Federated
2025 First end-to-end HHE-FL framework pairing PASTA cipher with BFV, cutting client uploads 2000x. hybrid (PASTA + BFV) CNN MNIST 97.6% (-1.3 vs plaintext 98.9%) — —
Swift: Fast Secure Neural Network Inference With Fully Homomorphic Encryption
FHE-SS exact ReLU
2025 FHE+SS hybrid hides ReLU/max-pool, beating Cheetah 7.4x on ReLU under WAN. CKKS CNN MNIST Not reported — —
BlindFL: Segmented Federated Learning with Fully Homomorphic Encryption
Segmented FHE FedAvg
2025 Segmented FedAvg halves CKKS aggregation time and blunts client-side gradient-inversion attacks. CKKS LeNet-5 / ResNet-20 MNIST + CIFAR-10 MNIST 98.53% / CIFAR-10 78.69% (vs 98.71% / 79.92% standard FL) — —
The Beginner’s Textbook for Fully Homomorphic Encryption
Beginner FHE textbook
2025 Self-contained mathematical textbook deriving TFHE, BFV, CKKS, BGV and their RNS variants from first principles. TFHE, BFV, CKKS, BGV N/A N/A N/A — GitHub
Building Privacy-Preserving AI system: AI Inference on Encrypted Data with Fully Homomorphic Encryption
Concrete ML production study
2025 Industrial feasibility study of Zama Concrete ML for TFHE inference on real-world XGBoost binary classifiers. TFHE XGBoost / Random Forest (binary classifier) Proprietary binary-classification (3000 records) 99% agreement (Model A); 22% agreement (Model B) — —
Exploring the future of privacy-preserving heart disease prediction: a fully homomorphic encryption-driven logistic regression approach
HE-aware LR for cardiology
2025 CKKS logistic regression outsources heart-disease training to the cloud with only 1% accuracy loss CKKS Logistic Regression Heart Disease (Kaggle) 84% (−1 pp vs plaintext 85%) — —
An Efficient Architecture for Edge AI Federated Learning With Homomorphic Encryption
Quant+Prune+Cluster FL
2025 Federated edge AI with CKKS, quantization, pruning, and clustering boosts accuracy 8.4% and cuts memory 35%. CKKS FCNN Human Activity Recognition (UCI HAR) 89.86% (+8.4% over FLH baseline) — —
Enhancing privacy-preserving machine learning with self-learnable activation functions in fully homomorphic encryption
Self-learnable polynomial activation
2024 Learnable polynomial activation lifts CKKS face-attribute accuracy 0.88-3.15% over square, with sub-second SNN variant CKKS CNN (SLAFNN-10 / SNN) UTKFace 88.07% gender / 89.16% age / 76.54% ethnicity (SLAFNN-10 ciphertext) 0.778 —
Practical Considerations of Fully Homomorphic Encryption in Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning
Practical FHE benchmarks
2024 Hands-on benchmarks show FHE inflates training/inference by 100x-1000x with notable accuracy drops from quantization. CKKS / BFV (via TenSEAL + Concrete ML) NN Classifier (Concrete ML) + XGBoost + Logistic Regression Breast Cancer (Kaggle) 91.23% XGB / 95.61% NN / 87.72% LR (vs 92.98%/96.49%/92.98% plaintext) 0.8 —
Private pathological assessment via machine learning and homomorphic encryption
FHE SVM kernels
2024 CKKS-based SVM inference on encrypted medical tabular and imaging data in seconds at 128-bit security. CKKS SVM Multiple F1 0.85 (PneumoniaMNIST, RBF); F1 0.96 (WBC, Sigmoid) 2.03 GitHub
Non-interactive Fully Encrypted Machine Learning Protocol for Inference
Non-interactive FE PPML
2024 First fully-encrypted FE protocol where the client never comes back online during inference. FE (DCR-based pkIPFE + LinEnc-QFE) FCNN (2-layer Quadratic Neural Network) Iris + Breast Cancer (UCI) Output error < 1e-7 vs plaintext; classification accuracy not reported 11952.0 GitHub
Federated Learning with Quantum Computing and Fully Homomorphic Encryption: A Novel Computing Paradigm Shift in Privacy-Preserving ML
FHE + Quantum FL
2024 CKKS-encrypted federated aggregation of hybrid classical+quantum neural network weights across 20 clients. CKKS Hybrid classical+QNN (parameterized quantum circuit) Multiple 88.75% Brain MRI; 70.12% CIFAR-10; 70.15% PCOS (test) — GitHub
Privacy-Preserving Graph-Based Machine Learning with Fully Homomorphic Encryption for Collaborative Anti-Money Laundering
TFHE graph-AML pipelines
2024 TFHE-encrypted XGBoost with graph features hits >99% accuracy on AML detection; GNN pipeline only partially compatible. TFHE GIN (GNN) + XGBoost-GFP AMLworld HI-Small 99.72% (FHE = clear) on balanced dataset; F1 0.3867 on imbalanced (+8% vs basic) [§6.4, §6.5] — GitHub
Secure Federated Learning With Fully Homomorphic Encryption for IoT Communications
Cluster-matrix FHE FL
2024 Four FHE+FL clustering variants for IoT botnet detection; up to 89.98% comm-overhead and 70.38% latency cuts. FHE (scheme not specified) CNN N-BaIoT 0.997 avg (OECM/MUCM/MECM); 0.911 (OUCM); baseline 0.996–0.998 [Tables III–VII] — GitHub
Recent advances of privacy-preserving machine learning based on (Fully) Homomorphic Encryption
FHE generations survey
2024 Tour of FHE-based PPML across four FHE generations, mixed-mode schemes, and hardware acceleration. survey (BFV, BGV, CGGI/TFHE, CKKS, mixed) N/A Multiple Not reported — —
Secure federated learning applied to medical imaging with fully homomorphic encryption
FL + CKKS last-layer
2024 Federated MobileNetV2 on Belgian mammograms encrypts only the last layer under CKKS due to RAM limits. CKKS MobileNetV2 (transfer-learned, binary head) Private Belgian mammograms 87.4% with HE vs 73.8% without (batch 32, 3 rounds, 3 clients) — —
Machine Learning Training on Encrypted Data with TFHE
TFHE encrypted training
2024 End-to-end encrypted SGD training of LR and small MLPs via TFHE rounding and 4-6 bit quantization. TFHE Logistic Regression + MLP (1 hidden) Multiple 98.25% (-0.87 vs fp32) breast-cancer LR — —
Efficiency Optimization Techniques in Privacy-Preserving Federated Learning With Homomorphic Encryption: A Brief Survey
HE-PPFL efficiency survey
2024 Taxonomy of algorithmic, hardware, and hybrid optimizations for HE-based federated learning on edge devices. survey (CKKS/BGV/BFV/TFHE/Paillier) N/A Multiple Not reported — —
HE-MAN – Homomorphically Encrypted MAchine learning with oNnx models
ONNX-driven FHE toolkit
2023 Auto-tunes Concrete (TFHE) or TenSEAL (CKKS) for any ONNX model with no FHE expertise required. hybrid (TFHE via Concrete, CKKS via TenSEAL) CNN (CryptoNets, LeNet-5, MobileFaceNets-classifier) Multiple 0.968 CryptoNets / 0.984 LeNet-5 / 0.970 LFW (Concrete, vs 0.975/0.991/0.990 plaintext) 112.0 GitHub
Optimized Privacy-Preserving CNN Inference With Fully Homomorphic Encryption
Constant-time conv FHE
2023 Coefficient-packed convolutions make FHE CNN cost constant in kernel size; 398 s for 94% on CIFAR-10. CKKS CNN (Plain-20 / Plain-18 variants) CIFAR-10/100, ImageNet 94.0% CIFAR-10 / 73.5% CIFAR-100 (state-of-art among FHE prior work) 398.0 GitHub
Practical Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning using Fully Homomorphic Encryption
FHE SVM training
2023 Trains a linear SVM on 8,000 encrypted samples in under 45 seconds via levelled CKKS and client-assisted Newton. CKKS SVM Wisconsin Breast Cancer (WBC) 99.1% (same as plaintext baseline) — —
Fully Homomorphic Encryption with Applications to Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning
Pedagogical FHE thesis
2023 Self-contained thesis from LWE foundations to GSW, CKKS, and a multikey-CKKS federated learning protocol. GSW, CKKS, xMK-CKKS N/A Not reported Not reported — —
FedML-HE: An Efficient Homomorphic-Encryption-Based Privacy-Preserving Federated Learning System
Selective parameter encryption
2023 Selective parameter encryption cuts HE-federated overhead ~10x for ResNet-50 and ~40x for BERT. CKKS Multiple (Linear, MLP, LeNet, RNN, CNN, MobileNet, ResNet-18/34/50, GroupViT, ViT, BERT, Llama-2 7B) Multiple Negligible delta (e.g. 0 to -0.28% on CNN vs plaintext) [Table 6] — —
FheFL: Fully Homomorphic Encryption Friendly Privacy-Preserving Federated Learning with Byzantine Users
Byzantine-robust multi-key FHE
2023 Single-server FL that defends against poisoning clients entirely under CKKS — no second server needed. CKKS (distributed multi-key additive) CNN / ResNet-18 Multiple 98.78% MNIST (-2.7 vs plaintext at N=16384, 100 users) — —
PPFLHE: A privacy-preserving federated learning scheme with homomorphic encryption for healthcare data
Federated Paillier + ACK
2023 Paillier-encrypted federated MobileNetV2 for diabetic retinopathy with ACK-based dropout handling. Paillier (PHE) MobileNetV2 APTOS 2019 Blindness Detection 81.53% (+1.53 vs prior FL [40]) — —
Secure human action recognition by encrypted neural network inference
Fast homomorphic convolution
2022 Skeleton-based fall detection under CKKS in 2.4 s with 613x speedup over LoLa. CKKS CNN (2D-CNN-128) J-HMDB + URFD + Multicam 86.21% sensitivity / 99.14% specificity (−0.16–0.17% vs plaintext) 2.419 GitHub
Homomorphic Encryption for Machine Learning and Artificial Intelligence Applications
Nuclear NDT motivation
2022 Argonne proof-of-concept: CKKS-encrypted FCNN on MNIST trades 7.7 pts accuracy for 150,000x slowdown. CKKS FCNN MNIST 76.1% (-7.7 vs 83.8% plaintext) 295.3 —
Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning With Fully Homomorphic Encryption for Deep Neural Network
First FHE ResNet-20
2022 First standard ResNet-20 on encrypted CIFAR-10 under RNS-CKKS with bootstrapping; 92.43% accuracy in ~3 h. RNS-CKKS ResNet-20 CIFAR-10 92.43% +/- 2.65% (vs 91.89% plaintext; 98.43% agreement) 10800.0 —
Exploring Bitslicing Architectures for Enabling FHE-Assisted Machine Learning
Bitsliced TFHE gates
2022 Software bitslicing over NuFHE gives 37x speedup for exact-FHE CNN inference in ~700 MB TFHE (NuFHE) CNN MNIST ~98% on MNIST after INT8 quantization (≤2% drop vs FP32) [§IV-A, Table VI] 16200.0 —
A Survey of Deep Learning Architectures for Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning With Fully Homomorphic Encryption
DL+FHE comparison metrics
2022 Cross-cuts FHE-PPML works by NN layer, activation, packing, bootstrapping and proposes hardware-independent comparison metrics. survey (BFV, BGV, CKKS, TFHE, YASHE) N/A Multiple Not reported — —
Fully Homomorphically Encrypted Deep Learning as a Service
Encrypted sequence model
2021 First CKKS encrypted 1D-CNN sequence model for agri-food milk-yield forecasting in a client-server EDLaaS pipeline. CKKS 1D CNN Langhill Dairy herd (30 years) 87.6% (MAPE 12.4%); MSE/MAE match plaintext to 3 s.f. 0.966 GitHub
Privacy-preserving neural networks with Homomorphic encryption: Challenges and opportunities
NN-HE survey + benchmark
2021 Survey of NN-HE with benchmark of CryptoNets and LoLa under SEAL+PyTorch on MNIST/F-MNIST. BFV (SEAL) + CKKS CNN MNIST, F-MNIST 98.95% MNIST (LoLa-N, SEAL); 99.51% plaintext PyTorch 3.5 —
Towards the AlexNet Moment for Homomorphic Encryption: HCNN, the First Homomorphic CNN on Encrypted Data With GPUs
First GPU HCNN
2021 First GPU-accelerated FHE CNN; MNIST in 5.16 s and CIFAR-10 in 304 s under BFV. BFV CNN MNIST + CIFAR-10 99% MNIST / 77.55% CIFAR-10 (scalar-encoded) 5.16 —
DOReN: Toward Efficient Deep Convolutional Neural Networks with Fully Homomorphic Encryption
Compressor-based accumulator
2021 Exact ReLU on encrypted CNNs via 3:2 compressors, 20x faster amortized than SHE. BGV CNN (VGG-7, ResNet-20, LoLa, GHE, SHE) CIFAR-10 Not reported — —
Private Machine Learning Classification Based on Fully Homomorphic Encryption
1-round HE compare
2020 Improved BGV scheme plus one-round homomorphic compare speeds private hyperplane, Naive Bayes, and decision-tree inference. BGV (improved HElib-style) decision tree / hyperplane / Naive Bayes Wisconsin Breast Cancer (UCI) Not reported 0.000177 —
A Survey on Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning with Fully Homomorphic Encryption
FHE+MLaaS survey
2020 Survey maps FHE families, bootstrapping, and MLaaS approaches to position privacy-preserving ML directions. survey (covers lattice, integer, (R)LWE, NTRU) N/A N/A (survey) Not reported — —
Homomorphic Encryption for Machine Learning in Medicine and Bioinformatics
Medical FHE survey
2020 Survey of FHE schemes, libraries, and privacy-preserving ML and genomics methods targeted at medical applications. survey (BGV, BFV, CKKS, TFHE, FHEW) N/A Multiple Not reported — —
On Fully Homomorphic Encryption for Privacy-Preserving Deep Learning
Bitwise bootstrapped CNN
2019 Bitwise Gentry-FHE CNN on MNIST exposes bootstrap-per-gate cost — projected ~10^12 s per image at lambda=9. Gentry bootstrapped FHE (AGCD + SSS) CNN MNIST 91.2% (plaintext float, full-match PR=1.0 at Q12.6 on NI=30) — GitHub
Fully Homomorphic Encryption for Machine Learning
Scale-invariant FHE-DiNN
2018 PhD thesis: TFHE per-neuron bootstrapping with sign activation gives depth-independent FHE for discretized neural nets. TFHE FCNN (DiNN, 1 hidden layer) MNIST 96.35% (-0.08 vs DiNN plaintext, -2.6 vs Cryptonets) 0.49 GitHub

The table is generated from the comparison: and frontpage: YAML blocks at the top of each summaries/*.md file. Do not edit rows by hand — edit the per-paper file and re-run the build (see How to contribute).

Glossary

How to contribute

To add a paper:

  1. Drop the PDF into papers/ (gitignored — local only).
  2. Convert it to text: pdftotext -layout papers/<filename>.pdf /tmp/<slug>.txt.
  3. Copy extraction-template.md to summaries/<slug>.md and fill in every section from the text, including the comparison: and frontpage: YAML blocks. Follow the slug convention firstauthor-year-shortid (lowercase, hyphenated).
  4. Re-run the build script to regenerate the comparison table and stats:
    python3 build_index.py
    

    The script reads every summaries/*.md front matter and rewrites the marker-delimited regions in this file and in summaries/index.md. Do not edit the rows by hand.

See extraction-template.md (per-paper schema) and frontpage-template.md (front-page schema, controlled vocabularies, anti-patterns).